+ Demand for Creative Cloud remains resilient. Creative Cloud revenue was US$2.8bn, up 8% YoY (13% YoY in constant currency). Creative Cloud annualized recurring revenue (ARR) grew by 8% YoY to US$11.3bn, adding US$307mn during the quarter. The growth was primarily driven by continued demand for its photography, imaging and video applications due to the surge in digital content creation. Key customer wins in 1Q23 include Accenture, Disney, BBC, and Nintendo.
+ Document Cloud strength continues. Document Cloud sales grew 13% YoY to US$634mn (16% YoY in constant currency) – the fastest growth of any segment in the quarter. Net new Document Cloud ARR was US$103mn, exiting the quarter with Document Cloud ARR of US$2.4bn. The growth was mainly due to its PDF capabilities and growth in e-signature transactions within Acrobat. Management noted that Acrobat is now the default PDF viewer in Microsoft Edge, which has an estimated 1bn users. Key customer wins in 1Q23 include HP, JPMorgan Chase, Samsung, and Verizon.
- Pressure from foreign exchange rates. Adobe’s revenue was negatively impacted due to the strengthening of the dollar against several key foreign currencies, including the Euro, British pound, and Japanese yen. In 1Q23, the unfavorable foreign exchange rate movement negatively impacted revenue by approximately US$200mn (or ~16% of PATMI).
+ Strong growth across business segments. In 4Q22, revenue grew 10% YoY (14% in constant currency) to US$4.5bn, which was in line with our estimates. The growth was driven by 10%/14% YoY increases in Digital Media and Digital Experience revenues to US$3.3bn and US$1.2bn, respectively. In the Digital Media segment, Creative Cloud revenue grew 8% YoY to US$2.7bn driven by strong demand for its design software tools (Photoshop, Adobe Express, and Frame.io) from creative professionals and smaller and medium-sized enterprises. Document Cloud revenue grew 16% YoY to US$619mn due to its PDF capabilities and growth in e-signature transactions within Acrobat. Digital Experience revenue, which includes analytics and marketing software, increased by 14% YoY to US$1.2bn. Key customer wins include Meta, Deloitte, and Delta Air Lines.
+ Maintained high margins. In 4Q22, Adobe reported an impressive gross margin of 87%. This is mainly because the company generates the majority of its sales (>90%) from recurring subscription revenue. Adj. operating margin (excluding stock-based compensation expense and amortization of intangibles) was 45%, which was in line with 4Q21. Adobe generated US$2.2bn in free cash flow in 4Q22. This translates to a 49% free cash flow margin.
- FX continues to be a headwind. Adobe’s revenue was negatively impacted due to the strengthening of the dollar against several key foreign currencies, including the Euro, British pound, and Japanese yen. In 4Q22, FX headwind to revenue was about US$175mn (15% of PATMI). Adobe projects nearly US$750mn headwind from FX in FY23e.
+ Document Cloud strength continues. Document Cloud revenue grew 23% YoY to US$607mn and Document Cloud annual recurring revenue (ARR) grew 26% YoY to US$2.2bn. The main growth drivers include strong demand for PDF solutions across computing devices and momentum in AdobeSign. Key customer wins in 3Q22 include Amazon, Boeing, and ServiceNow. Document Cloud is accelerating document productivity and workflows with over 300bn PDFs opened and nearly 8bn e-signatures processed each year. Adobe also announced enhancements to Acrobat web experience such as High Contrast and Read Out Loud.
+ Demand for Creative Cloud remains robust. Creative Cloud revenue was US$2.6bn, up 11% YoY. Adobe added US$330mn of net new Creative Cloud ARR in 3Q22. Much of the Creative Cloud revenue growth was supported by significant growth in new users (particularly in Creative Cloud Express) and continued momentum in growth initiatives such as Frame.io and Substance. The demand for its photography, imaging and video applications was strong due to the surge in digital content creation.
+ Resilient Digital Experience. Digital Experience revenue grew 14% YoY to US$1.1bn driven by strength in the enterprise segment with large deal wins and continued momentum for Adobe Experience Platform applications. Workfront remained strong as well with revenue growing above 35% YoY. Key customer wins include T-Mobile, Morgan Stanley, and Qualcomm.
- Acquisition of Figma is expensive and dilutive. Adobe has signed a definitive merger agreement to acquire collaborative design software firm Figma for US$20bn. The deal values Figma at almost 50x its FY22e ARR of US$400mn. Adobe noted it could lower margins by 100-200 bps over the next two years. Management also expects the deal to be accretive to adjusted EPS only at the end of year three (FY26). The transaction will be funded by 50% cash and 50% stock, and is expected to close in FY23, subject to regulatory and shareholder approval.
For 4Q22e, Adobe expects GAAP EPS of US$2.44 (adj. EPS of US$3.50) on total revenue of US$4.52bn. Adobe also expects Digital Media net new ARR of US$550mn for 4Q22e driven by price increases at renewals in both Creative and Document Cloud segments. Additionally, the company expects revenue growth of 10%/13% YoY in the Digital Media and Digital Experience segments. While acquiring fast-growing Figma may boost Adobe’s growth rate and give it a competitive advantage, the huge acquisition price is expected to have an impact on profitability.
+ Adobe reports record 2Q revenue with solid demand for its products. Revenue grew 14% YoY to US$4.4bn, beating consensus estimates for its top line by 1%, and was in line with our estimates. The growth was driven by 15%/17% YoY increases in Digital Media and Digital Experience revenues to US$3.2bn and US$1.1bn, respectively. In the Digital Media segment, Creative Cloud revenue grew by 12% YoY to US$2.6bn (Creative Cloud annual recurring revenue (ARR) grew 14% YoY to US$10.8bn), while Document Cloud sales grew 27% YoY to US$595mn (Document Cloud ARR grew 26% YoY to US$2.1bn) – the fastest growth of any segment in the quarter. The growth primarily came from new user acquisition and healthy retention. In 2Q22, Acrobat Web surpassed 50mn monthly active users, and doubled YoY. Additionally, Document Cloud revenue was driven by strong adoption of Acrobat with integrated Sign capabilities within companies of all sizes and significant demand for PDF solutions on mobile devices.
+ Maintained strong margins. Adobe reported an impressive gross margin of 88% as the company reports the bulk of its sales from recurring revenue. Operating income was 35% of sales compared with 37% a year ago. Non-GAAP operating margin, which excludes stock-based and deferred compensation expense and amortization of intangibles, was 45% compared with 46% a year ago. Adobe has stable operating margins despite the macroeconomic headwinds, representing a disciplined spending approach and a higher focus on profitability.
+ Creative Cloud price increases. In April, Adobe increased its subscription fees for certain Creative Cloud plans for the first time in five years. The new pricing was in effect for roughly a month but generated about US$10mn in additional revenue, in line with the management’s expectations. Meanwhile, the impact of the price increases is expected to be higher in 4Q22 as significant enterprise deals will be up for renewal.
- FX headwinds impacting revenue growth. Adobe is factoring in an incremental FX headwind of US$175mn across 2H22 revenue. This year, the US dollar has gained strength against the Euro, the Japanese yen, and other currencies as the Federal Reserve has raised interest rates to combat inflation. Adobe generates about 40% of its revenues from international markets.
For FY22, Adobe now expects earnings of US$9.95 per share on total revenue of US$17.65bn (prev. EPS of US$10.25 on revenue of US$17.9bn). Non-GAAP EPS is expected to be US$13.50 compared with the prior forecast of US$13.70. This guidance reduction was driven by the projected US$175mn incremental foreign exchange headwinds, US$75mn revenue hit due to the ongoing Ukraine conflict, increased tax rates, and summer seasonality in 3Q22.
Adobe expects Digital Media net new ARR of US$1.9bn for FY22. Additionally, the company expects revenue growth of 12%/14% YoY in the Digital Media and Digital Experience segments.
Cash flow generation continues to be strong, with the company generating about US$1.9bn in Free Cash Flow, ending 2Q22 with US$3.4bn in cash and cash equivalents.
+ Document Cloud continues to be Adobe’s fastest growing segment. Document Cloud revenue grew 17% YoY to US$562mn and Document Cloud ARR grew 29% YoY to US$2.0bn. Much of the Document Cloud revenue growth was supported by strong customer demand for Acrobat subscriptions; momentum in AdobeSign, with significant YoY increase in e-sign transactions within Acrobat; and high demand for PDF solutions on mobile devices.
+ Strong operating margins. Strong margins have been an important aspect of our Adobe investment thesis, and 1Q22 was no exception. The company posted operating margin of 37% in 1Q22, which was in line with 1Q21. Margins benefitted from lower travel/facilities costs amid a peak in Omicron cases in December and January.
+ Price increase for Creative Cloud products. Adobe has revealed its intention to increase pricing of its Digital Media products late in the second quarter. This could boost Creative Cloud revenues in 2H22 as price hikes take effect at renewal for existing customers and for new customers. Adobe believes that it has delivered significant value to customers by introducing several platform innovations and products, including mobile and web-based Creative Cloud Express offerings. While no specifics are available, the last price rise was announced in 2017.
- War in Russia and Ukraine impacts Digital Media segment. Adobe has stopped selling products and services in Russia and Belarus due to the ongoing Russia-Ukraine conflict. The company has announced that it is decreasing its Digital Media ARR balance by US$87mn, consisting of US$75mn relating to sales in the Russia/Belarus region and an additional US$12mn pertaining to Ukraine (although the company will continue to provide Digital Media services to the latter). Further, Adobe's FY22 sales will be reduced by US$75mn due to these adjustments.
- Higher tax rate. In 1Q22, Adobe reported tax rate of 18% compared to the company’s guidance of 16%. This was mainly because of the lower-than-expected tax benefits related to stock-based compensation. Further, the tax rate outlook for 2Q22 increased to 20%. Assuming everything else is constant, the increased tax rate reduces EPS by US$0.06 each quarter.
Adobe expects 2Q22 revenue of US$4.34bn and earnings of US$2.44 per share. The company expects Digital Media net new ARR of US$440mn. Additionally, Adobe anticipates revenue growth of 13% and 15% for the Digital Media and Digital Experience segments, respectively.
Adobe did not provide an update to its FY22 prior guidance. For FY22, Adobe expects earnings of US$10.25 per share on total revenue of US$17.9bn. Among the other guidance metrics are 14% as-reported revenue growth for Digital Media and Digital Experience segments.
Maintain BUY with lower TP of US$602.00 (prev. US$658.00)
We lower our FY22e PATMI by 2% to reflect an estimated US$75mn revenue hit from the business disruption associated with Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Digital media creation tools and cloud document management systems are in high demand globally across several industries. Despite the war-based revenue reductions, we maintain BUY with a lower target price of US$602.00. Valuations based on DCF with a WACC of 6.4% and terminal growth of 4.0%.
Adobe (ADBE) offers software for creative content and marketing purposes, with an emphasis on user experience. Its revenue segments are Digital Media (73% of FY21 revenue), Digital Experience (25%), and Publishing and Advertising (2%). While most people are familiar with Adobe's Acrobat product, Adobe's Creative Cloud segment includes more than 20 photo and video edit applications, including Photoshop (Figure 1) and Illustrator.
We initiate coverage with a BUY rating. Our target price is US$658 based on a DCF valuation with a WACC of 6.2% and terminal growth of 4.0%.
Adobe has three revenue segments: Digital Media (73% of FY21 revenue) comprising revenue from two major business units Creative Cloud and Document Cloud; Digital Experience (25%) including revenue from Experience Cloud Subscription; and Publishing and Advertising (2%) consisting of revenue from a diverse range of legacy products and services. Main markets are the Americas (57%), EMEA (27%), and the APAC (16%).
Total revenue expanded at 22% CAGR in the past five years (Figure 2). Growth was driven by Digital Media and Digital Experience which grew at 22% and 23% CAGR respectively in the past three years (Figure 3). We expect these two segments to continue strong growth driven by digital transformation initiatives, solid demand for cloud document management (Figure 4), and enterprise momentum with Digital Experience. Acquisitions like Frame.io and WorkFront, as well as new product launches, might contribute incrementally.
Cost of sales and total operating expenses grew 18% CAGR in the past five years. Cost of sales was 12% of FY21 revenue, while Research and Development (16%), Sales and Marketing (27%), General and Administrative (7%), and Amortization of Intangibles (1%) made up operating expenses. Total Operating Expense as a percentage of revenue has been reducing over the last 5 years, from 61% in FY16 to 51% in FY21, leading to improved operating and gross margins.
Gross margins hit an all-time high of 88% in FY21, up by 160 basis points (bps) from FY20. Gross margins appear to be on an upward trend over the past five years, and we expect this to continue because of the increased scalability of the business.
Net margins (reported) in FY21 were 31%, down from 41% the previous year. The change is primarily because of the one-time tax benefits completed during FY20. Adobe anticipates margins to fall slightly because some savings (such as T&E) are expected to be rolled back into the model in FY22e.
Assets: Cash and cash equivalents decreased by about US$0.6bn YoY in FY21 to US$3.8bn, largely due to share repurchases and acquisitions. Plant, property and equipment for FY21 was US$1.7bn, an increase of US$156mn from the previous year, largely due to ongoing CAPEX spending. The company’s current ratio for FY21 was 1.2x.
Liabilities: Current liabilities for FY21 were US$6.9bn, almost US$1.4bn more than FY20. This increase was mainly due to a rise in accrued expenses and deferred revenue. Non-current liabilities saw a jump of US$4mn in FY21. Adobe had a net debt position of US$279mn in FY21 (Figure 5). ADBE’s debt-to-equity ratio remains low at only 0.3x.
Cash-flow from operations has steadily grown at 27% CAGR to US$7.2bn (Figure 6) from FY17 to FY21. CAPEX stood at US$0.3bn in FY21, at 11% CAGR over FY17-21. In FY21, Adobe generated US$6.9bn in free cash flow. This translates to an enviable 44% free cash flow margin. Adobe's ability to generate large amounts of cash allows it to acquire firms or return cash to shareholders (repurchase). The software company has a share repurchase authorization of up to US$13.1bn expiring in 2024.
The rise of digital content has been the secular tailwind driving Adobe’s growth story over the last few years. As of FY21, about 92% of ADBE’s revenue is recurring and derived from subscription models.
Digital Media (73% FY21 revenue). ADBE reported Digital Media revenue of US$11.5bn, representing 25% YoY growth. Products in this segment fall under two categories:
1) Creative Cloud – This provides applications and services for photography, video/film, animation, design; and
2) Document Cloud – This offers solutions to create, edit, approve, share, scan, and sign secured digital documents.
Creative Cloud is the core of ADBE’s business, as it has consistently accounted for ~60% of total revenue over the last few years. It grew from US$5.3bn in FY18 to US$9.5bn in FY21 (Figure 7). And on an ARR basis, Creative Cloud accounted for 84% of total Digital Media ARR in FY21. Creative Cloud revenue growth was driven by new user acquisitions on the ADBE website, strength in the Creative Cloud Teams product offering, and focus on co-selling Frame.io with its Creative Cloud enterprise offerings. Frame.io is a cloud-based video collaboration platform that enables editors and key project stakeholders to collaborate using cloud-based workflows. Furthermore, content creation and consumption across devices is growing. We expect that Creative Cloud adoption will continue to rise at a healthy rate even when the economy recovers.
Within Creative Cloud, Adobe has developed a robust and comprehensive platform that eliminates the need for users to have external sources for fonts, storage, and stock photos. In addition, we think Adobe could capture market share across several emerging technologies like 3D and augmented reality. Adobe has identified a US$63bn TAM for Creative Cloud in 2024, up from US$41bn in 2023. This TAM comprises US$25bn from creative professionals, US$31bn from communicators, and US$7bn from consumers. We expect Creative Cloud revenue to grow 13% in FY22e.
ADBE reported Document Cloud revenue of US$2bn in FY21, representing 32% YoY growth (Figure 8). The COVID-19 pandemic drove business operations online from offline at an accelerated pace. Business operations that were previously done on paper had to be converted to a digital format overnight. This has fueled the company's Document Cloud business, and we expect it to continue to do so. Adobe estimates its Document Cloud business to represent a US$32bn opportunity in 2024, up 52% from US$21bn in 2023. We expect Document Cloud revenue to grow 19% in FY22e.
Digital Experience (25%). Digital Experience provides tools to analyze marketing spend, optimize advertisements, and manage ad campaigns. The Experience Cloud platform includes four product categories:
ADBE reported total Digital Experience revenue of US$3.9bn in FY21, representing 24% YoY growth (Figure 9). Experience Cloud Subscription revenue was US$3.4bn with a growth of 27% YoY. This was driven by a seasonally solid quarter for Enterprise activity with subscription bookings increasing by more than 50% YoY in the fourth quarter of 2021. Also, Adobe Experience Platform customers increased by 300% YoY in FY21.
In Experience Cloud, we believe Adobe is well-positioned to benefit from the significant surge in e-commerce and rising demand for enhanced customer experiences anytime, anywhere. We also see Adobe’s strategic acquisition of Workfront as a significant growth driver for this segment. Adobe projects Digital Experience TAM to be US$110bn by 2024, a 29% increase from the 2023 estimated TAM. We expect Digital Experience revenue to grow 14% in FY22e.
Publishing and Advertising (2% FY21 revenue). The publishing and advertising segment is the legacy portion of ADBE’s business. It includes printing technology, e-learning solutions, and web conferencing applications. This business’ revenue has been falling, but only makes up 2-3% of the company's total revenue.
The surge in digital content over the last decade is a long-term growth driver to Adobe’s numerous businesses, and we believe that trend will not slow down anytime soon.
Creative Cloud. The market for Creative Cloud remains significant and growing. According to Statista, the global creative software segment is expected to see a CAGR of 5% between 2022 and 2026 to reach US$10.8bn. The growth in creative jobs, adoption of latest mediums, high-quality innovative communication, and surge in people posting on social media platforms are all broadening the customer universe. ADBE’s key competitors in the Creative Cloud market include CorelDRAW, Affinity, Autodesk, and Getty Images.
Document Cloud. According to MarketsandMarkets, the global e-signature market is expected to see a CAGR of 33% between 2021 and 2026 to reach US$16.8bn. The primary reasons that are expected to fuel the growth of the e-signature market include increased spending on digital documents by government agencies and companies, improved security with a regulated and seamless workflow, and enhanced end-to-end customer experience.
Notably, research firm IDC recently recognized Adobe as the leading provider of e-signature software, though DocuSign is ahead (Figure 10). ADBE’s other competitors in the e-signature market are Box and Dropbox.
Digital Experience. According to Grand View Research, the global digital experience platform market size, valued at an estimated US$10.2bn in 2021, is set to reach US$22.9bn in value by 2028, which indicates a 12% CAGR. The US digital experience market size is expected to see a CAGR of 13% (Figure 11). The main drivers for this expected growth are increased preference of companies to deliver personalized and optimized user experience and engagement across several marketing channels. ADBE’s key competitors in the market include Salesforce.com, Microsoft, and Oracle.
We initiate coverage on Adobe Inc. with a BUY rating and a price target of US$658.00. Our valuation is based on DCF valuation, using a 6.2% WACC and 4.0% terminal growth rate (Figure 12).
Rule of 40
The Rule of 40 is a metric that measures the balance between growth and profitability. It considers revenue growth and EBITDA margin, the total of which must be more than 40% to satisfy the criteria.
The sum of ADBE’s three-year average revenue growth of 20% and EBITDA margin of 42% equals 62%, which fulfils the Rule of 40 criteria.